Skip to content

Filter Pitchers and Cartridges Compared

Reviewed on November 19, 2026

Different filters do different jobs. A filter that helps with chlorine taste might leave hardness alone. So the useful question isn't "which filter", it's "which problem".

The basic idea

Wikipedia says filters use processes such as sieving, adsorption and ion exchange to remove unwanted substances from water.1 Those are three different mechanisms, and a given cartridge may use one or several. Jug filters can be used for small quantities of drinking water.1

Some kettles even have built-in filters, primarily to reduce limescale build-up.1 That shows how closely scale and filtering are linked.

Carbon

Activated carbon is a form of carbon commonly used to filter contaminants from water and air.2 It works by adsorption, a process where atoms or molecules adhere to a surface.2

Wikipedia says activated carbon can interact with chlorine, and a carbon block is also sold as a CTO filter, short for chlorine, taste, odor.2

The saved sources tie carbon to chlorine, taste and odor. They don't say carbon changes hardness, so don't count on it for scale.

Ion exchange

Ion exchange can be used to remove hardness from water by exchanging calcium and magnesium ions for sodium ions in an ion-exchange column.3 Wikipedia says conventional household softening appliances depend on an ion-exchange resin.4 A pitcher cartridge's label should say what its filter medium is.

The trade is worth knowing about. The calcium and magnesium leave, and sodium or potassium comes in. Wikipedia notes softened water may also contain elevated levels of sodium or potassium.5

Wikipedia says the exchanger can be regenerated by washing with an excess of the ions it should hold, and that water softeners are usually regenerated with brine.3

Reverse osmosis and distillation

Wikipedia calls distillation and reverse osmosis the most widely used two non-chemical methods of water softening.4 Whether that suits your machine is a question for the maker, so read your manual first. Here's how to track it down.

Side by side

Type What the sources link it to
Activated carbon Filtering contaminants, chlorine, taste and odor2
Ion exchange resin Swapping calcium and magnesium for sodium3
Reverse osmosis, distillation Non-chemical softening4
Built-in kettle filter Reducing limescale build-up1
Choosing a filter by the problem it solvesName the problem: chlorine, hardness, scaleMatch it to a filter typeRead the cartridge's own labelFollow the maker's replacement schedule
Match the filter type to the thing in your water you want changed.

Cartridges in the machine

Some machines take their own cartridge. One maker says its cartridge must be replaced approximately every 50 litres of water or at least every 2 months.6 The same page says a changed cartridge needs priming, so refer to the instructions on how to prime it.6

The maker's replacement schedule applies to its own cartridge, so follow your manual rather than the numbers above.

Before you buy

Get your water's hardness first, in the water report or by testing at home. Then read the filter's label for what it says it does. Check afterward with a test, since a filter's claim and your water can differ.

Where the facts come from

  1. Water filter, Wikipedia
  2. Activated carbon, Wikipedia
  3. Ion exchange, Wikipedia
  4. Water softening, Wikipedia
  5. Hard water, Wikipedia
  6. User manual and frequently asked questions EXPRESSO ESPRESSERIA AUTOMATIC, Krups