A home test gives you a number for one glass of water on one day. That's useful, as long as you know what the tool measures and where it stops.
TDS meters
TDS stands for total dissolved solids. Wikipedia describes it as a measure of the dissolved combined content of everything in the water, and says TDS in water can be measured using a digital meter.1 It's often given in parts per million (ppm).
Here's the catch. A TDS meter doesn't weigh anything. It uses an electric current through the water and reads how well the water carries it. Ions in the water make it conduct, and the meter turns that reading into a TDS figure.1
How close is it? Wikipedia says that when correlated with laboratory TDS measurements, conductivity provides an approximate value for the TDS concentration, with around 10% accuracy.1 It also says conductivity-based methods are appropriate if inorganic salts comprise the great majority of TDS.1
What a TDS number can't do is tell you which minerals are present. A given reading could be mostly calcium or mostly something else. It's a total, not a recipe.
Drop kits
Some kits ask you to add a measured sample to a vial, put in drops of a reagent one at a time, and watch for a color change. That pattern is called titration.
Wikipedia describes it as adding small volumes of a titrant to a sample with an indicator until the indicator changes color.2 It adds that single drops, or less than a single drop, can make the difference between a permanent and a temporary change.2 In plain terms, be careful when counting.
The same method is used for alkalinity in a lab, where the sample is titrated with a strong acid.3 Follow your kit's own instructions, including any handling warnings on the reagent.
Test strips
Strips and kits all come with their own directions. Follow them for timing, rinsing and how to read the color chart. This site hasn't saved a source for how accurate strips are, so it won't give you a figure.
Check the unit before you compare
Results come in different units. Hardness might be in ppm, mg/L or grains per gallon, and alkalinity has its own unit.3 Water Hardness Explained has the conversions. A kit that reports in grains and a report that lists mg/L describe the same water in different words.
When someone else should do it
Wikipedia calls gravimetric methods the most accurate for TDS.1 That means evaporating the water and weighing what's left, which is a lab job.
For hardness, the USGS says information relevant to a home or immediate locale should be provided by the local health agency or local water utility.4 Ask your supplier, then use a home test to check it. Your supplier's numbers are covered on the water report page.
One more thing. Test the water you actually put in the machine. If you fill the tank from a pitcher or bottle, test that, not the kitchen tap. A filter pitcher can change the result.
Where the facts come from
- Total dissolved solids, Wikipedia
- Titration, Wikipedia
- Alkalinity, Wikipedia
- Hardness of Water, U.S. Geological Survey